How do I choose which FPL player to buy?

Use our player comparison tools to review form, fixture difficulty, and historical performance. Get a clear recommendation for the best player to transfer or captain for this gameweek.

How can I find the best FPL captain pick?

FPL.my’s detailed stats and expected returns analysis help you choose the player with the highest upside for captaincy each gameweek.

Herrington or Shaw | FPL PlayerComparison

Please select a player from the suggestions

GW9 data · last compared 1 day ago

Defender

Herrington

Hull City, HUL

Defender

Shaw 🏥

Man Utd, MUN

🏆 Shaw wins 6 of 10 of data comparisons

4.0M

Cost

4.2M

Total Points

0.8

Points Per Game

2.4

0.5%

Selected By

4.7%

Goals Scored

Assists

Clean Sheets

242

Minutes Played

425

9.3

ICT Index

23.1

0.0

Form

1.0

💰 Shaw is the value pick - 2.86 pts per £m (Herrington 1.25 vs Shaw 2.86)

🎯 Herrington is your differential (0.5% owned) - Shaw is the template pick at 4.7%

Fixtures

Hull City

IPS 2 (H) - 2026-10-31
ARS 5 (A) - 2026-11-07
BHA 3 (H) - 2026-11-22
CRY 3 (A) - 2026-11-29
NFO 3 (H) - 2026-12-02

Man Utd

CHE 4 (A) - 2026-10-31
AVL 3 (H) - 2026-11-08
LIV 4 (A) - 2026-11-22
BRE 3 (H) - 2026-11-28
NEW 3 (A) - 2026-12-02

📅 Herrington has the easier run over the next 5 (avg difficulty 3.2 vs 3.4)

FPL Advisor Recommendation

Herrington

19.4

Shaw

28.6

Medium Confidence

Recommendation: Transfer in Shaw

Key Factors:

Better current form (1.0 vs 0.0)
Better value for money
More secure playing time

Other Considerations:

⚠️Shaw: Unspecified injury - Unknown return date

Shaw (Man Utd, £4.2m, 12 points) is the better FPL pick over Herrington (Hull City, £4.0m, 5 points) as of Gameweek 9, and Herrington also has the easier next five fixtures (3.2 vs 3.4 average difficulty).